Submissions: Your Feedback

Submissions from people and organisations who have agreed to have their feedback published are provided below.

The views expressed in these submissions belong to their authors. The National Indigenous Australians Agency reserved the right not to publish submissions, or parts of submissions, that include, for example, material that is offensive, racist, potentially defamatory, personal information, is a copy of previously provided materials, or does not relate to the consultation process.

An auto-generated transcript of submissions provided as attachments has been made available to assist with accessibility. These transcripts may contain transcription errors. Please refer to the source file for the original content.

Please note not all submissions are provided in an attachment. For submissions without an attachment, click on the name of the person or organisation to view the text.

Site functionality has recently been improved. You can now search by participant name and submission number. You can also click on the number, date and participant column headings to sort the order of submissions.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are advised that submissions may contain images or names of deceased people.

If you require any further assistance please contact Co-designVoice@niaa.gov.au.


Submission Number
Submission date
Main Submission File
Main Submission Automated Transcript

Indigenous Voice

I do not agree with the proposal to introduce a separate indigenous voice to government. To me
this smacks of identity politics, the special treatment for one group of Australians over the rest. As
our anthem states “we are one and free”. If we have a separate voice for aboriginals, then why not
one for Somalians, Vietnamese, Italians etc? This is just the politics of grievance.
Division is death, setting up one group against others is just wrong. More than ever, in these
difficult times, we should be looking to strengthen Australian not divide it.
Why is a separate voice needed? I have read Marcia Langtons article in the Australian, dated Jan
9, but I am not persuaded of any special, extraordinary need. Aboriginals already have a voice in
government through the vote, just like all other Australians.

A voice at local, regional and national levels would involve setting up a huge bureaucracy, with
accompanying large costs. It would also effectively become a third chamber, after the house of
Reps and Senate. Government is already unwieldy enough without an added level of bureaucracy.
If Aboriginals want a greater say in government then join a political party or stand for election.

Who would speak for the various indigenous groups? I understand there are hundreds of different
tribes throughout Australia, we already see how difficult it is for any group to engage with an
Aboriginal group and get a firm single response. There is no common voice. To get a
representative voice separate indigenous elections would be called across the nation, again at
huge time and cost. The proposal for equal quotas for male and female reeks of left wing identity
politics. It sounds good but doesn’t work, all it does is push out the best candidate in favour of
the “right” candidate.

Regarding funding, we have seen time and again how indigenous groups are mismanaged and
funds are squandered. (ref ATSIC and numerous YPG land groups).

Why are Aborignals disadvantaged? Are they disadvantaged? I am sorry but I do not understand
why a separate voice would help their plight. To me it appears that, on the contrary, Aboriginals
are afforded every special treatment, with endless government funding and hand outs. Most of
this appears to be wasted. I am not stopping any person in Australia from getting ahead. To me
Aboriginals are not oppressed or disadvantaged. I consider all Australians as equals, I admire any
Australian who makes good, whether they are Somalian, Italian or other.

If the argument is that remote Aboriginal groups do not have necessary services, such as medical
and education, and they don’t have employment opportunities, then in my view they either put up
with this reality or do something about it. So there needs to be a recognition that the government
cannot afford to build police stations, schools and hospitals in every remote district. And if people
want these services and opportunities they need to move to be closer to them.

As background to my view and comments I want to tell you my little family history. My grandfather
lived at Cobden, VIC and worked on the road gang at the Heytesbury Shire all his life. He worked
as a wood merchant in his spare time to make a bit of extra money. My father worked on dozers
before working himself through night school to become an estimator at Ford. I have been
fortunate enough to make it through Uni, (only just, I am a C grade student) and only due to free
fees during the Whitlam years. I took a punt and set up my own business 20 years ago, and it has
supported our family of three kids.
I am proud to say that all of us earned every cent we got and none of our generations ever took
the dole. So I have a very big problem with any groups looking for “special” treatment, or free
handouts from others.

To me this proposal is not about getting a better deal for indigenous peoples, it is all about
identity politics, grievance and rent seeking. Time for our indigenous to get over themselves and
join with all Australians to make our great nation ever better.



We acknowledge the Traditional Owners and custodians of country throughout Australia and their continuing connection to land, waters and community. We pay our respects to the people, the cultures and the Elders past, present and emerging.