Submissions: Your Feedback

Submissions from people and organisations who have agreed to have their feedback published are provided below.

The views expressed in these submissions belong to their authors. The National Indigenous Australians Agency reserved the right not to publish submissions, or parts of submissions, that include, for example, material that is offensive, racist, potentially defamatory, personal information, is a copy of previously provided materials, or does not relate to the consultation process.

An auto-generated transcript of submissions provided as attachments has been made available to assist with accessibility. These transcripts may contain transcription errors. Please refer to the source file for the original content.

Please note not all submissions are provided in an attachment. For submissions without an attachment, click on the name of the person or organisation to view the text.

Site functionality has recently been improved. You can now search by participant name and submission number. You can also click on the number, date and participant column headings to sort the order of submissions.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are advised that submissions may contain images or names of deceased people.

If you require any further assistance please contact Co-designVoice@niaa.gov.au.


Submission Number
Susan Downes
Submission date
Main Submission File
Main Submission Automated Transcript

Submission of Co-Design of Indigenous Voice to Parliament

Thank you for your hard work in compiling the Indigenous Voice co-design process interim report 2020. I
am very keen to have an Indigenous Voice to parliament, comprised of a National Voice, and Local and
Regional Voices. The Voice will improve self-determination, which is key to improving indigenous rights,
closing the gap between indigenous and non-indigenous Australians in areas of health, life expectancy,
rates of incarceration and so on.

I am addressing the options suggested in the co-design models of the voice to parliament.

• The Voice should have at least 18 members (not 16). The Voice requires at least 2 members for
each state, territory and the Torres Strait Islands, because even the areas with smaller indigenous
populations still have a large responsibility to share. The members would need resources, staffing
and indigenous contacts based on the indigenous population in their area.
• Funding would need to include paying the 18 members, administration staff, legal advice, research
teams and payment for local and remote area indigenous people to have the capacity to collect
data and canvas opinions in their areas.
• Membership terms of 4 years (or longer) are essential to make a proper impact. A term of 4 years
allows adequate time for proper consultation. Terms should be staggered so that only half the
members are replaced at one time, allowing the accumulated knowledge to be preserved and
transferred to new members.
• In order to enhance the Respectful Long-term Partnerships principle, members should not be
limited to 2 terms. Politicians in Australia do not currently have a limit on the number of terms they
can stay in power, and neither should the members of the Voice.
• Initially, having members with prior experience working in Government and political roles would be
useful because they would know how to negotiate with federal politicians and government officials,
and this would be key to having the Indigenous Voice heard early on during the process of drafting
new laws. They would understand the requirements of writing submissions and reports, tabling
documents for review by politicians and they could train newcomers. Finally, they would be able to
set up a partnership interface with contacts in local and remote areas to get the information
required to properly serve their needs.
• A National Voice is very important because federal laws can help drive public opinion to improve
the status of indigenous people.
• I agree that the Voice should not be a structure that supplies services because historically that dual
structure was very complicated and ineffective. The Voice should have enough flexibility to change
and grow.
• The Voice should not be set up as a business structure. It should run as a government funded
organization. This would be a more reliable structure, ensure adequate funding and prevent the
Voice from being sidetracked from its core mission by funding and structural concerns.
• A previous imprisonment should not prevent you from becoming a member, (as demonstrated by
Nelson Mandella), especially as the incarceration rates for indigenous people in Australia are so
• The National Voice will have a right and responsibility on behalf of indigenous Australians to advise
Parliament and the Government with regards to any matters that members deem to be significant.
Furthermore, I wish to address the following points beyond the scope of the co-design of Indigenous
Voice to Parliament. I support the Uluru Statement From the Heart, which influences the following
co-design input.

• The Voice to Parliament must be enshrined in the constitution. This requires that a referendum be
held in the next term of parliament. Australians will be voting at the referendum on the final model
that comes from this co-design process of the Voice to Parliament. If the referendum succeeds, the
model will determine the legislation.
• The Voice to Parliament must consider the voices of remote, rural and city regions.
• The Makarrata process can be fulfilled once both sides have come together to deal with the wrongs
from the past and the ongoing injustices, with a National Treaty and Truth Telling.
• I want a National Treaty that pays a high price for what happened and for what is still happening.
• I want a truthful history of Australia to be taught.
I am a non-indigenous Australian citizen, born in Australia. I am now 60 years old, and my de facto husband
and I have two Australian children, and we own a house on a suburban block. I trained and worked as a
Registered Nurse, Registered Midwife, Accountant/bookkeeper (currently employed part time). I volunteer
at Australians for Native Title and Reconciliation (ANTaR), an independent, national non-government, not-
for-profit, community-based organisation which advocates for the rights of Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander people in Australia and aims to help overcome disadvantage. Previously I volunteered (part time in
accounts) at the Metropolitan Local Aboriginal Land Council (MLALC). I am a member of the Women’s
Reconciliation Network, Redfern.

I suffer grief over the history of terrible suffering that First Nations People have incurred since being
invaded, because of the outrageous decision to claim terra nullius instead of at least negotiating a treaty,
because of the massacres, enforced removal to missions, working for unpaid wages (slavery) and having a
generation of their children stolen. I suffer grief when I continue to see racism, police brutality, high rates
of incarceration and deaths in custody, racist reporting in the news and another generation of children
being removed.

It was amazingly generous of the First Nations representatives to come together and write the Uluru
Statement From the Heart. They kindly presented non-indigenous Australians with an invitation to resolve
our conflicts and to finally recognize their Voice in the constitution, make a treaty and have a truthful
history. To watch this invitation being swept aside out of hand by Malcolm Turnbull was a truly terrible
thing for me to witness. I felt so much shame at that moment.

I am pleading with all Australians to come together to right these wrongs and ease my suffering and more
importantly to ease the continued suffering of the First Nations People. I cannot see how that suffering will
ever stop, but I want to try to ease it and to stop it getting worse!

I am just a blip in time on my suburban block of land compared to the thousands of years the First Nations
People have had a relationship with this land. I was not alive in 1788, but I am now, and I can take
responsibly by not standing by and watching the continued racism and atrocities.